Black Like Her

JUNE 15, 2015

BY

Cobb-Black-Like-Her-1200

Rachel Dolezal, president of the Spokane chapter of the N.A.A.C.P., in March.

On June 7th, Elinor Burkett published an Op-Ed in the Times expressing what she portrayed as a feminist’s reluctant skepticism about aspects of the transgender movement. She argued, in part, that the notion of men simply transitioning into women was equivalent to a white person darkening his or her skin and professing to be black. The example was meant as a reductio ad absurdum—but, less than a week later, Rachel Dolezal, the president of the Spokane, Washington, chapter of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People and a professor of Africana studies, was unveiled as a white woman who has for some years presented herself and identified as black. On Monday, Dolezal resigned, in a statement that didn’t answer questions about what she referred to as “my personal identity,” though it did refer obliquely to “challenging the construct of race.” That answer is clearly inadequate; many people have challenged the construct of race without lying about their lives. But there is something more worth discussing here.

The easy presumption about Dolezal, who has two white parents and light skin and eyes—and hair that has ranged from blond to brown, though she has worn it in ways that are culturally associated with black women—is that this is an instance in which someone finally pointed out the obvious: the emperor is naked. But, in truth, Dolezal has been dressed precisely as we all are, in a fictive garb of race whose determinations are as arbitrary as they are damaging. This doesn’t mean that Dolezal wasn’t lying about who she is. It means that she was lying about a lie.

Dolezal’s name has been added to a running discussion of racial appropriation. Two weeks ago, Chet Haze, the putative rapper and son of the actor Tom Hanks, took to Instagram with a questionable syllogism. Because hip-hop is, in his view, “not about race,” and because he so closely identifies with the genre, he should be allowed to use the word “nigger” (or its variant “nigga”) without recrimination. His comments recalled the feeble musings of John Mayer, five years ago, when he lamented to Playboy that his level of black cred was high enough, his standing within the race so unimpeachable, that he ought to be able to toss the epithet with the same sort of entitlement as Jay Z. And last week, the Washington Post published a timeline of the career implosion of Iggy Azalea, the white Australian rapper notable for her transparent racial affectations.

Among African-Americans, there is a particular contempt, rooted in the understanding that black culture was formed in a crucible of degradation, for what Norman Mailer hailed as the “white Negro.” Whatever elements of beauty or cool, whatever truth or marketable lies there are that we associate with blackness, they are ultimately the product of a community’s quest to be recognized as human in a society that is only ambivalently willing to see it as such. And it is this root that cannot be assimilated. The white Negroes, whose genealogy stretches backward from Azalea through Elvis and Paul Whiteman, share the luxury of being able to slough off blackness the moment it becomes disadvantageous, cumbersome, or dangerous. It is an identity as impermanent as burnt cork, whose profitability rests upon an unspoken suggestion that the surest evidence of white superiority is the capacity to exceed blacks even at being black. The black suspicion of whites thus steeped in black culture wasn’t bigotry; it was a cultural tariff—an abiding sense that, if they knew all that came with the category, they would be far less eager to enlist.

But this is precisely what makes the Dolezal deception complicated. Artists like Eminem and Teena Marie, white people who were by and large accepted by black people as a legitimate part of black cultural life, nonetheless had to finesse a kind of epidermal conflict of interest. Irrespective of their sincerity, a portion of their profitability lay in their status as atypically white. Dolezal’s transracialism was imbued with exactly the opposite undertaking. She passed as black and set about shouldering the inglorious, frustrating parts of that identity—the parts that allocate responsibility for what was once called “uplifting the race.” It’s an aspect of her story that at least ought to give her critics—black ones, particularly—a moment of pause.

Dolezal is, like me, a graduate of Howard University, a place where the constellation of black identities and appearances is so staggeringly vast as to ridicule the idea that blackness could be, or ever has been, any one thing. What I took from Howard, besides that broadened sense of a world I’d presumed to know, was an abiding debt to those who’d fought on its behalf and a responsibility to do so for those who came afterward. It’s easy to deride Dolezal’s dishonesty—to ridicule her hoax as a clever means of sidestepping the suspicion with which white liberals are commonly greeted—until we reflect on a photograph of Walter White, the aptly named man who served as the second black president of the N.A.A.C.P. Or one of Louis T. Wright, who served as the national chairman of the N.A.A.C.P. board during the Great Depression. In the nineteen-twenties, amid a feud with the organization, the black nationalist Marcus Garvey criticized the N.A.A.C.P. for being a organization whose black and white members were essentially indistinguishable.

The spectrum of shades and colorings that constitute “black” identity in the United States, and the equal claim to black identity that someone who looks like White or Wright (or, for that matter, Dolezal) can have, is a direct product of bloodlines that attest to institutionalized rape during and after slavery. Nearly all of us who identify as African-American in this country, apart from some more recent immigrants, have at least some white ancestry. My own white great-grandparent is as inconsequential as the color of my palms in terms of my status as a black person in the United States. My grandparents had four children: my father and his brother, both almond-brown, with black hair and dark eyes, and two girls with reddish hair, fair skin, freckles, and gray eyes. All of them were equally black because they were equal heirs to the quirks of chance determining whether their ancestry from Europe or Africa was most apparent. Dolezal’s primary offense lies not in the silly proffering of a false biography but in knowing this ugly history and taking advantage of the reasons that she would, at least among black people, be taken at her word regarding her identity.

http://www.newyorker.com/news/daily-comment/rachel-dolezal-black-like-her

Advertisements

10 thoughts on “Black Like Her”

  1. Online loan application must be duly filled by the borrower and must be submitted to the lender.
    In many cases, payday loan repayment fees are considerably less than the overdraft
    rates many UK banks would demand. Unfortunately, Paul’s car didn’t share
    his aspirations and not far down the road, the car coughed and died.

    Like

  2. Fulfill an application form with the required details as regards your earnings and bank account.

    Everything can be done in the comfort of his home or
    office. We should hope for the best but prepare for the worst.

    Like

  3. Online loan application must be duly filled by the borrower and must be submitted to the lender.
    In many cases, payday loan repayment fees are considerably less than the overdraft rates many
    UK banks would demand. Individuals can also have an opportunity to utilize these deals irrespective of his poor fiscal standing.

    Like

  4. I’m truly enjoying the design and layout of your blog.
    It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more enjoyable for me to
    come here and visit more often. Did you hire out a
    designer to create your theme? Fantastic work!

    Like

  5. After exploring a handful off the articles on your web page,
    I really appreciate your way of writing a blog. I book marked it
    to my bookmark site list and will be checking back
    in the near future. Please check out my website too and let me know your opinion.

    Like

  6. Online loan application must be duly filled by the
    borrower and must be submitted to the lender. The amount borrowed then has to be
    repaid over a period of 3 months. So if this is repeated statewide
    then it’s a huge problem for their criminal justice system.

    Like

  7. Online loan application must be duly filled by
    the borrower and must be submitted to the
    lender. Right now you can go for the best monetary support of the consolidate payday loans.

    Everyone faces financial crisis once in a lifetime and cannot tally his spending with his earnings.

    Like

  8. You need to choose a lender who provide direct deposit.
    In many cases, payday loan repayment fees are
    considerably less than the overdraft rates many UK banks would demand.
    Individuals can also have an opportunity to utilize these deals irrespective of his poor fiscal standing.

    Like

  9. to find out more information on our company and payday loan practices.
    Now you can avail financial help instantly and without any hassle through instant approval health insurance.
    The borrowers if desire can also seize supplementary
    time for arrangement but will then are obliged to forfeit further sum in the form of very well.

    Like

Comments are closed.